ESPN SPORTS

GENERAL CONVERSATION BOARDS => Mafia Games => Completed Games => Topic started by: Talon on July 08, 2018, 10:55:09 AM

Title: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: Talon on July 08, 2018, 10:55:09 AM
(https://arynews.tv/en/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/The-Punisher.jpg)
THE RULES

- Vote in BOLD and on a separate line of text to help the mods when compiling votes for the vote counts.
Example:

Quote
I think Talon is clearly scum, he just knows too much.  I'm going to

Vote Talon

Until he proves to me he is town I will leave my vote here.

- The same rules apply for unvoting.

- There will be no secretive hidden text, don't try to hide crap in your posts etc etc.

- No talking about the game outside of the game thread or your mod-assigned QT.

- You are not dead until the moderator says you are dead, however once enough votes have been cast for a lynch, the lynch will stand.  No amount of unvoting will save you; but who knows... something else might, so fight like hell.

- Once you are dead, you are dead.  Do not post anymore.  You are permitted a BAH post, and nothing more.

- There will be No Night Talking allowed in this game.  Once Day phase ends, SHUT UP.

- If you have a night action you must PM it to me before deadline or it will not be counted.

- Missing night actions may result in a penalty.  Missing multiple night action submissions may result in a mod-kill.  Please submit "NO ACTION" if you have an action and are choosing not to use it.

- As always, Role/Character claiming is allowed but is definitely discouraged.  The game is more interesting when you have to think... but you have to do what you have to do I guess.

- Day phases will last 48 Hours.  Night Phases will last a minimum of 24 Hours.

- Do not quote anything sent to you from the Mod.  That includes role PM information, or anything you may receive in a PM or QT from the Mod.  If it is something I want everyone to know, it will be posted in the game thread. Clear?

- Remember to have fun, avoid personal attacks, and don't take things too seriously.  If someone is offending you PM your mod and I will talk to the player in question.

- Inactivity will result in prods, replacements, and eventually mod-kills... Please don't make me mod-kill anyone.  Stay active, stay involved, and show off your mafia skills!


DO NOT POST UNTIL INSTRUCTED TO IN THE THREAD FOR THE START OF DAY ONE.



CAST
1. Mike Powers as ???
2. John "Pancho" Chacon as Karen Paige -  x1 Town Governor - Killed Night 3
3. Jon "Hilterquest" Hallquist as ???
4. Buckson "BBQ" Gooch as ???
5. Gravedigger as Lewis Wilson -- Town Paranoid Gun Owner - Lynched Day 5
6. Justin P as Sarah Leiberman - Vanilla Townie - Lynched Day 4
7. Kirk Xi as Curtis Hoyle - Town Doctor - Killed Night 5
8. C.J. Gates as Carson Wolf - Mafia Goon - Killed Night 2
9. Johnny Rebel as ???
10. T-Bone as Dinah Madani - Town Cop - Killed Night 1
11. Eli as Leo Lieberman -- Vanilla Townie - Lynched Day 6
12. James "Metro"Major as ???
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: Talon on July 08, 2018, 11:34:25 AM
Maria: "Wake up sleepy head."

Frank: "What time is it?"

Maria: "10 O'Clock... but its okay, you need your rest.  ...and now that you're home, we have plenty of time... I'm going to go get the kids.."

Frank Castle's recurring dream haunted him... every night it was the same.  Watching his family die over and over and over.  ...and in this dream, it was always him pulling the trigger.

DEAD --- Talon / Maria Castle --- Game Moderator

Frank thought he had killed everyone connected to his family's murder, but suddenly there was reason to believe that was not the case.  It's time for some Punishment.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROZQ8S6QEmU


IT IS NOW DAY 1 --- YOU HAVE UNTIL 12PM TUESDAY JULY 10TH TO REACH A LYNCH

WITH 12 ALIVE IT TAKES 7 TO LYNCH!

PLAYER LIST
Powers
Pancho
Jon
Gooch
Gravedigger
Justin
Kirk
Gates
Rebel
T-Bone
Eli
Metro
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM T-Bone on July 08, 2018, 12:27:24 PM
Vote: Franchise
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Jon on July 08, 2018, 12:48:48 PM
This is real easy gents. Just do as I do...

Vote: Pancho
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Kirk on July 08, 2018, 12:56:38 PM
You don't think it's mean to pile on the misery when he's about to be fired in Alabama?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Gooch on July 08, 2018, 01:55:25 PM
Got my role. This game looks like fun.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Pancho on July 08, 2018, 02:19:59 PM
Ahhh day one ....

Twelve players at least 3 mafia unless you want to probably include a third party.

Vote: Gooch

Fun game means he has a fun role. I lean mafia.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Gooch on July 08, 2018, 02:28:47 PM
Go for it, bub. You'll enjoy the result.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Powers on July 08, 2018, 03:10:57 PM
Ahhh day one ....

Twelve players at least 3 mafia unless you want to probably include a third party.

Speculating on set-up in your very first post? 

Vote Pancho
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: Talon on July 08, 2018, 03:20:05 PM
(http://i63.tinypic.com/ehm6gh.jpg)

DAY 1 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Pancho (Jon, Powers)

1 -- Gooch (Pancho)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Gravedigger, Justin, Kirk, Gates, Rebel, T-Bone, Eli, Metro


With 12 Alive it takes 7 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12-Noon (Eastern Time) Tuesday.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 08, 2018, 04:06:24 PM
Vote: Eli

Welcome to Mafia..
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Gates on July 08, 2018, 04:11:31 PM
Role received.

Time to shake off the rust.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: Talon on July 08, 2018, 05:37:57 PM
(http://i63.tinypic.com/ehm6gh.jpg)

DAY 1 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Pancho (Jon, Powers)

1 -- Gooch (Pancho)

1 -- Eli (Gravedigger)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Justin, Kirk, Gates, Rebel, T-Bone, Eli, Metro


With 12 Alive it takes 7 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12-Noon (Eastern Time) Tuesday.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Justin on July 08, 2018, 07:26:13 PM
Checking in.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Kirk on July 08, 2018, 07:33:40 PM
Speculating on set-up in your very first post? 

Vote Pancho

I'm in two minds about that statement. If you are not at least thinking about the potential set-up of the game, you haven't given yourself any foundations for constructive input on day 1. Saying it out loud seems unnecessary, however, and could even be manipulative.

At this point, I think Pancho was simply trying to spark conversation.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Rebelicious on July 08, 2018, 07:38:17 PM
What's Mafia?

Role received.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Powers on July 08, 2018, 07:53:19 PM
I'm in two minds about that statement. If you are not at least thinking about the potential set-up of the game, you haven't given yourself any foundations for constructive input on day 1. Saying it out loud seems unnecessary, however, and could even be manipulative.

At this point, I think Pancho was simply trying to spark conversation.

It'd be sparking conversation about nothing. If it were day 3-4, when we'd have info to go on, I could concede your point. Day1 though?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Kirk on July 08, 2018, 07:59:09 PM
Actually, I think talking about it on day 3/4 is potentially more manipulative. On day 1, you either find something to talk about or just spend the day making jokes and random votes.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Eli on July 08, 2018, 09:19:24 PM
Hello I am ready to mafia.

Role received

Also insert something really insulting toward Digger here.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Pancho on July 09, 2018, 09:04:48 AM
Day 1 is going to be a waste unless you spark a conversation. I appreciate Gooch felt the need to comment on my vote.

Powers though come on thought. Must you snipe any attempt at a conversation.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM T-Bone on July 09, 2018, 09:41:07 AM
Vote: Powers
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Gooch on July 09, 2018, 09:59:56 AM
I like where this is going. Vote for me again, Panch.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Jon on July 09, 2018, 10:04:49 AM
Have we not evolved enough to where conversation on Day 1 is a good thing and not a bad thing?

Gooch is always a difficult read because you could hand the man a bag full of crap and heíd try to look at the positive side of it. Heís also a really easy person to target for an early lynch  because he probably hurts himself more by trying to defend his actions.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Metroll on July 09, 2018, 10:50:05 AM
Playing via mobile ... I think we should vote Rebel to avoid the mod kill when he goes inactive. 😂😂😂😂. ❤️ Ya J-Reb.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Rebelicious on July 09, 2018, 07:12:09 PM
Playing via mobile ... I think we should vote Rebel to avoid the mod kill when he goes inactive. 😂😂😂😂. ❤️ Ya J-Reb.

That's just rude.

I'm here for the showwww.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: Talon on July 09, 2018, 10:56:12 PM
(http://i63.tinypic.com/ehm6gh.jpg)

DAY 1 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Pancho (Jon, Powers)

1 -- Gooch (Pancho)

1 -- Eli (Gravedigger)

1 -- Powers (Bone)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Justin, Kirk, Gates, Rebel,  Eli, Metro


With 12 Alive it takes 7 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12-Noon (Eastern Time) Tuesday.

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Pancho on July 09, 2018, 11:22:36 PM
Question for Powers. What should a first post contain other than NOT discuss set up?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Powers on July 10, 2018, 12:51:56 AM
Day 1 is going to be a waste unless you spark a conversation. I appreciate Gooch felt the need to comment on my vote.

Powers though come on thought. Must you snipe any attempt at a conversation.

Calling you out for a BS post is not "sniping an attempt at conversation". C'mon man.


Question for Powers. What should a first post contain other than NOT discuss set up?

Obviously some people joke, some people try to jump right in with content. It appears to me that you attempted the latter, but in either the laziest or scummiest way possible (the jury is out as to which).

How you gonna speculate on a game setup 5 posts in? What purpose does it serve? What information are you using to base your assumption on?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Pancho on July 10, 2018, 01:35:46 AM
Calling you out for a BS post is not "sniping an attempt at conversation". C'mon man.


Obviously some people joke, some people try to jump right in with content. It appears to me that you attempted the latter, but in either the laziest or scummiest way possible (the jury is out as to which).

How you gonna speculate on a game setup 5 posts in? What purpose does it serve? What information are you using to base your assumption on?

Rude to answer a question with a question. Please answer my original question. Donít tell me what people do. Tell me what should be in a day one post. Need an example like so.

Calling you out for a BS post is not "sniping an attempt at conversation". C'mon man.


Obviously some people joke, some people try to jump right in with content. It appears to me that you attempted the latter, but in either the laziest or scummiest way possible (the jury is out as to which).

How you gonna speculate on a game setup 5 posts in? What purpose does it serve? What information are you using to base your assumption on?

Why would I speculate? Multiple reasons. Eli admittedly has never played the game. Trying to lay out the game as clearly and as early as possible doesnít give the mafia the room to create reasonable doubt.

That also answers your second question about purpose.

Iím using my role. Using the number of people signed up. Same information everyone has on day one.

Now do you wish to actually present something or just going to try and negate me. 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Powers on July 10, 2018, 01:40:51 AM
There is no answer to what "should be" in a day 1 post. You know this as well as I do.

Just like you know that modding the mod is no bueno.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: Talon on July 10, 2018, 02:02:24 PM
(http://i63.tinypic.com/ehm6gh.jpg)

FINAL DAY 1 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Pancho (Jon, Powers)

1 -- Gooch (Pancho)

1 -- Eli (Gravedigger)

1 -- Powers (Bone)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Justin, Kirk, Gates, Rebel,  Eli, Metro





IT IS NOW NIGHT 1.  YOU HAVE 36 HOURS TO SUBMIT YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS -- DEADLINE IS 2AM THURSDAY MORNING (EASTERN)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Pancho on July 10, 2018, 02:21:51 PM
There is no answer to what "should be" in a day 1 post. You know this as well as I do.

Just like you know that modding the mod is no bueno.

So after all that. Nothing

But hey at least weíve engaged the whole town in a conversation right where everyone contributed their opinions. Oh whatís that. Everyone kept joking and is going to waste the first day.

Well you try.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: GM Gooch on July 10, 2018, 02:44:44 PM
You boys are fun.

I've missed this.

Good to have you back Powers. Pancho, you're a delight.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 1
Post by: Talon on July 10, 2018, 02:56:22 PM

- There will be No Night Talking allowed in this game.  Once Day phase ends, SHUT UP.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 10, 2018, 09:26:12 PM
It was a typical night around the city... People tucked into their beds feeling safe, not realizing the evils that threatened their very lives here in the homeland.  While some chose to do nothing on this night, others were busy.    Very busy.

Inside of an apartment downtown FBI Agent Dinah Madani stands in her bathroom, looking at her reflection in the mirror.  She ponders a few things as her casual love interest Billy Russo walks into the room behind her, admiring her frame as he approaches.

"You know, if you stare at yourself much longer people will start to think I'm rubbing off on you."

"Oh please, I couldn't be that vain if I tried pretty boy..."

Billy clinches his fist tightly, the joke clearly irritating him as he steps up even closer, pinning her to the counter-top.  He slowly pulls a knife out of waistband of his pants and begins positioning it for a swift stroke.

"...It's funny Madani... You're so obsessed with finding who's behind all that shit in Kandahar that you never realized how close you were to the answer.."

"What?---UGGGHHHHHHHH"

Madani's eyes grow wide as she rapidly processes the information but its too late....  Billy plunges his blade into her torso over and over until she is left dead on the floor of her own bathroom...

The next morning the rest of the town realizes what has occurred, finding T-BONE Dead.


(https://img.sharetv.com/shows/characters/thumbnails/marvels_the_punisher.dinah_madani.jpg)
DEAD -  T-Bone --- Agent Dinah Madani -  Town Cop




IT IS NOW DAY 2 --- WITH 11 ALIVE IT TAKES 7 TO LYNCH!  --- DEADLINE IS 10 PM THURSDAY NIGHT (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Jon on July 10, 2018, 11:32:28 PM
I think it's pretty pointless to have an argument about what good day 1 conversation is. It allows two players to take up the majority of posting and leaving the rest to just sit and watch as the day phase came to a close.

I don't think either way we get anywhere near a Day 1 lynch, but I don't want to see players just get back with just a check in post and adding nothing to the game.

Unless anyone has anything of substance to go off of, we're right back to where we were Day 1 and now down the Town Cop.

Pancho and Powers: You're both pride ridden players who love to win an argument or at least see it out to its conclusion. Nothing really screams scum about either of your play in Day 1, but at the same time... I could see you both creating a scene like that to distract. I'm linking you both for the time being.

Digger/Justin/Rebel/Metro/Gates: 1 check in post is all ya'll did in Day 1. I think it's fairly obvious scum is among this group.

I'm going to begin with those 5 names as I'd like to see their reasoning for only a check in post adn to also engage them in some Day 2 banter. Let's start with...

Vote: Gates
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gates on July 11, 2018, 06:34:10 AM
I kept forgetting to check the mafia section further down the board, thatís why I only had the one post. This is what happens when we donít have mafia for awhile lol. I will do a better job going forward so that I can add in more of a contribution.

Beyond that I donít have anything to add from last night. Iím of the mind that one of Powers or Pancho are scum, I just donít know which one as of yet. Iím going to go back and read their argument/discussion to see.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Kirk on July 11, 2018, 06:58:49 AM
Vote: Powers

T-Bone was voting Powers and now T-Bone is dead.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Eli on July 11, 2018, 07:19:40 AM
Seems too obvious to me for Bone to have been killed for voting Powers this early on. I think Kirk is trying to exploit something that, on the surface, might seem "obvious" so....


Vote: Kirk
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Metroll on July 11, 2018, 07:45:50 AM
Simple - Monday was travel day and my new project wonít let me into ďgamesĒ websites at their office which also has no cell reception in our room.

As for the game I donít mind Eliís WIFOM assertion but Iím more in tune with Kirks thinking.

Vote:Powers
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Kirk on July 11, 2018, 09:36:54 AM
Seems too obvious to me for Bone to have been killed for voting Powers this early on. I think Kirk is trying to exploit something that, on the surface, might seem "obvious" so....


Vote: Kirk

It's so obvious, that nobody would do that... which makes it the perfect thing to do. INSERT INCEPTION BWAH HERE.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Pancho on July 11, 2018, 09:48:36 AM
Kirk with the huge WIFOM!

Vote: Kirk
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Justin on July 11, 2018, 09:50:14 AM
It's so obvious, that nobody would do that... which makes it the perfect thing to do. INSERT INCEPTION BWAH HERE.

I understand your point on this, but don't think Powers would really do it.

Seems too obvious to me for Bone to have been killed for voting Powers this early on. I think Kirk is trying to exploit something that, on the surface, might seem "obvious" so....


Vote: Kirk

I'm inclined to think Eli and Kirk are in cahoots and they are trying to appear on opposite ends of the spectrum.

Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Jon on July 11, 2018, 11:39:27 AM
I understand your point on this, but don't think Powers would really do it.

I'm inclined to think Eli and Kirk are in cahoots and they are trying to appear on opposite ends of the spectrum.

Vote: Eli

Unvote

If thatís the case why split the vote up?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gooch on July 11, 2018, 11:47:13 AM
Unvote

If thatís the case why split the vote up?

That's what I was thinking. If it looks like a train is building on Kirk and you believe that Kirk and Eli are connected, why put a vote on Eli?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Justin on July 11, 2018, 11:48:26 AM
Unvote

If thatís the case why split the vote up?

Because I don't think Pancho will stick with his vote which leaves only Eli voting for Kirk and he's going to stick his vote there to make him look less suspect.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Metroll on July 11, 2018, 12:31:18 PM
Because I don't think Pancho will stick with his vote which leaves only Eli voting for Kirk and he's going to stick his vote there to make him look less suspect.

Not going to lie - this sounds like a very rehearsed answer. I'd auto-vote Eli for something like that because of how new he is and think someone fed it too him.
 
In this case I'm just going to FOS: Justin.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Justin on July 11, 2018, 12:38:22 PM
Not going to lie - this sounds like a very rehearsed answer. I'd auto-vote Eli for something like that because of how new he is and think someone fed it too him.
 
In this case I'm just going to FOS: Justin.

Well it came from my brain so I guess you could call it rehearsed.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Jon on July 11, 2018, 02:15:02 PM
Vote: Justin
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Kirk on July 11, 2018, 02:50:08 PM
Kirk with the huge WIFOM!

Yeah, but why not?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Pancho on July 11, 2018, 03:29:34 PM
Because the definition of WIFOM means I can answer your question with but why?

Also donít base anything off my vote. It doesnít count. Justin couldnít have known that
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Kirk on July 11, 2018, 04:18:46 PM
It's an argument based on an action the mafia has actually taken. If you're not looking at the mafia's moves and trying to decide why they did what they did, what exactly are you doing?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2:
Post by: GM Gates on July 11, 2018, 07:07:11 PM
Vote: Kirk

That seems like too obvious a move and that you are trying to piggy back off the argument from Day One to catch the inactives into a mis-lynch.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Metroll on July 11, 2018, 08:03:57 PM
Also donít base anything off my vote. It doesnít count. Justin couldnít have known that

Can you vote tomorrow?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 11, 2018, 08:19:10 PM
 
(https://i2.wp.com/78.media.tumblr.com/3e03518b8b466013a828bc5c862f7d6b/tumblr_p3aajy2kmh1rcn1qfo2_400.gif?w=605&ssl=1)

DAY 2 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Powers (Kirk, Metro)

1 -- Kirk (Pancho, Gates)

1 -- Eli (Justin)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Rebel,  Eli, Powers, Gravedigger


With 11 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 10PM(Eastern Time) Thursday.

   
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Eli on July 11, 2018, 08:20:33 PM
Vote: Kirk

Did I forget that in my earlier post?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 11, 2018, 08:23:07 PM

(https://i2.wp.com/78.media.tumblr.com/3e03518b8b466013a828bc5c862f7d6b/tumblr_p3aajy2kmh1rcn1qfo2_400.gif?w=605&ssl=1)

DAY 2 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Powers (Kirk, Metro)

2 -- Kirk (Pancho, Gates, Eli)

1 -- Eli (Justin)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Rebel, Powers, Gravedigger


With 11 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 10PM(Eastern Time) Thursday.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Pancho on July 11, 2018, 09:00:36 PM
Can you vote tomorrow?

So far as I know Iím not a stump
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gooch on July 11, 2018, 09:29:56 PM
I don't think Kirk is mafia. Just not playing scummy. I won't be throwing a vote on him and would recommend voting for others. Kirk is town.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2:
Post by: GM Kirk on July 11, 2018, 10:07:32 PM
That seems like too obvious a move and that you are trying to piggy back off the argument from Day One to catch the inactives into a mis-lynch.

We're at a stage in mafia history where the obvious moves are the safest for the mafia to make. If you kill the person who was going after you, everyone says it's too obvious or that someone is likely framing you. It's the most effective way of silencing opposition and it's safe because of attitudes like the one Gates and Eli have towards it. Time to go full circle and chase down the obvious plays.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 11, 2018, 11:28:31 PM
We're at a stage in mafia history where the obvious moves are the safest for the mafia to make. If you kill the person who was going after you, everyone says it's too obvious or that someone is likely framing you. It's the most effective way of silencing opposition and it's safe because of attitudes like the one Gates and Eli have towards it. Time to go full circle and chase down the obvious plays.


It feels way too obvious, like we're being hit over the head with it... Not buying the "obvious = scum" theory...

Vote: Kirk

As for my inactivity, anyone who's been in a game with me knows I'm spotty at best when it comes to posting...
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Rebelicious on July 11, 2018, 11:36:38 PM
Iím inclined to check on Gates. I find it slightly odd that as soon as Kirk throws out his lame ďnobody talks in day one so theyíre scum!Ē post that he immediately comes on and says he doesnít remember where the Mafia forum is?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gooch on July 11, 2018, 11:41:02 PM
Kirk is town.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Kirk on July 12, 2018, 01:50:48 AM
Iím inclined to check on Gates. I find it slightly odd that as soon as Kirk throws out his lame ďnobody talks in day one so theyíre scum!Ē post that he immediately comes on and says he doesnít remember where the Mafia forum is?

Jon did that, not me.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 12, 2018, 09:33:14 AM

(https://i2.wp.com/78.media.tumblr.com/3e03518b8b466013a828bc5c862f7d6b/tumblr_p3aajy2kmh1rcn1qfo2_400.gif?w=605&ssl=1)

DAY 2 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Powers (Kirk, Metro)

3 -- Kirk (Pancho, Gates, Eli, Digger)

1 -- Eli (Justin)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

Not Voting -- Gooch, Rebel, Powers


With 11 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 10PM(Eastern Time) Thursday.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gates on July 12, 2018, 10:26:00 AM
Iím inclined to check on Gates. I find it slightly odd that as soon as Kirk throws out his lame ďnobody talks in day one so theyíre scum!Ē post that he immediately comes on and says he doesnít remember where the Mafia forum is?

I didnít say I forgot where it is, I said that I hadnít checked because itís been awhile since we had a game (let alone a game Iíve played) and it had slipped my mind.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Eli on July 12, 2018, 11:36:34 AM
The fact that Gooch is so adamantly "Kirk is town" makes me suspicious of him too. Almost is trying to hard to sway people in that direction. Sticking with my vote on Kirk for the time being though.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gooch on July 12, 2018, 03:07:49 PM
The fact that Gooch is so adamantly "Kirk is town" makes me suspicious of him too. Almost is trying to hard to sway people in that direction. Sticking with my vote on Kirk for the time being though.

I play my hand pretty early. I know Kirk is town. That's not just me chirping in. I have proof, but that will be neglected.

If you think I'm scum, throw a vote on me, pal. See what happens.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Justin on July 12, 2018, 04:27:31 PM
I'm comfortable leaving my vote on Eli.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gooch on July 12, 2018, 04:29:55 PM
That's not a bad idea.

Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Eli on July 12, 2018, 04:59:58 PM
I play my hand pretty early. I know Kirk is town. That's not just me chirping in. I have proof, but that will be neglected.

If you think I'm scum, throw a vote on me, pal. See what happens.

If you've got proof, bub, then throw it out there. Otherwise you're just talking to talk.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Gooch on July 12, 2018, 05:05:54 PM
Absolutely my allegations against you are only talk. It's been one night...I have one action. I can confirm someone is town. That's the proof I have because we aren't allowed to share a message from the mod...so you've got all the proof you're going to get. You fighting it is scummy.

Keeping an eye on you.

(https://media.giphy.com/media/n6Gk6pAMeP9NS/giphy.gif)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Metroll on July 12, 2018, 05:22:55 PM
Kirk - how do you feel about Gooch saying you are town. Do you know if he is town?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: GM Pancho on July 12, 2018, 05:35:52 PM
Unvote

Vote: Metro

Guaranteed. Of course this is being done as merely a show since it doesnít count.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 12, 2018, 06:41:24 PM

(https://i2.wp.com/78.media.tumblr.com/3e03518b8b466013a828bc5c862f7d6b/tumblr_p3aajy2kmh1rcn1qfo2_400.gif?w=605&ssl=1)

DAY 2 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Powers (Kirk, Metro)

3 -- Kirk (Gates, Eli, Digger)

1 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

0 -- Metro (Pancho)

Not Voting -- Rebel, Powers


With 11 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 10PM(Eastern Time) Thursday.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 12, 2018, 11:50:42 PM
(https://uproxx.files.wordpress.com/2016/03/punishergif.gif?w=650)

FINAL DAY 2 VOTE COUNT

2 -- Powers (Kirk, Metro)

3 -- Kirk (Gates, Eli, Digger)

1 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

0 -- Metro (Pancho)

Not Voting -- Rebel, Powers



NO LYNCH!



IT IS NOW NIGHT 2, YOU HAVE 36 HOURS TO SUBMIT YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS -- DEADLINE TO SUBMIT IS 12 NOON SATURDAY.

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 14, 2018, 12:16:03 PM
Another night in the city, and the scum is out again. BILLY RUSSO is out to do more damage after having eliminated Agent Madani the night before.  Tonight he has one man in his sights.. As he approaches the door to his home, he is caught off guard by a familiar voice.

"...A little late for you to be creeping on my block, isn't it brother?"

"Curtis?  What are you doing out? These streets are dangerous enough when you've got both your legs."

"Well you know, I just thought with some of the shit that's been going on lately, I better make sure nothing like that goes down again tonight... so what about you? What are you doing here?"

"Nothin... Just out for a stroll... but you be safe, you never know who's out there waiting in the shadows.."


With that BILLY leaves, unable to kill his target, walking off into the night as CURTIS HOYLE looks on cautiously.


......Meanwhile


CJ GATES heads home.... little does he know FRANK CASTLE is waiting for him.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0zWUT1vqRIk


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-J7torMEF4

(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338817.jpg)
DEAD -  CJ Gates --- SAIC Carson Wolf -  Mafia Goon



IT IS NOW DAY 3 --- WITH 10 ALIVE IT TAKES 6 TO LYNCH!  --- DEADLINE IS 12 NOON MONDAY  (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 14, 2018, 12:21:38 PM
Well, now I feel a bit stupid having voted the same as Mafia....
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Metroll on July 14, 2018, 12:26:07 PM
Vote: Powers

Maybe people will listen to me today.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 14, 2018, 12:32:08 PM
Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 14, 2018, 01:48:35 PM
Well that's an interesting turn of events. Pretty suspicious of Kirk still, but I'm going to roll with Metro today and back his vote.

Vote: Powers
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 2
Post by: Talon on July 14, 2018, 01:56:33 PM
(https://78.media.tumblr.com/3cb14a4ecde7cbfa428ac353a9dc4a22/tumblr_ozmqdizZGH1r5dpsxo1_540.gif)

DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


 2 -- Powers (Metro, Eli)

1 -- Eli (Gooch)


Not Voting --  Powers, Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger, Justin, Kirk, Rebel


With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 14, 2018, 01:58:18 PM
Well that's an interesting turn of events. Pretty suspicious of Kirk still, but I'm going to roll with Metro today and back his vote.

Vote: Powers

"I expect rhyme and reason from Gooch...but hey, I'll just bandwagon a vote with no evidence because I like the cut of his jib today."

Any reason to follow Metro? My vote could be swayed.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 14, 2018, 02:07:52 PM
"I expect rhyme and reason from Gooch...but hey, I'll just bandwagon a vote with no evidence because I like the cut of his jib today."

Any reason to follow Metro? My vote could be swayed.

That will sway you? Maybe not. I'm sort of in the same boat as Digger in that I'm not all that comfortable with the fact that I voted along with mafia. The temptation is to keep my vote on Kirk because I'm still suspicious. But Kirk made the assertion that Bone had voted for Powers and Bone died that night. Maybe they're right and my WIFOM assertion was wrong. I'm willing to throw my vote behind them and see where it leads today in the hope that, perhaps, we'll get more information if we get the needed six votes.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 14, 2018, 04:13:09 PM
My goodness people. You really think I'm so thin skinned that I'd kill Bone for voting me on Day 1? Lololol.

Gooch, question for you. You've said that you know Kirk is town. Now that another night has passed, can you clear another player? Or was the Kirk thing a 1 time deal?

I really hate Digger's post that started the day, but in a weird way it makes me think he's town. I don't think scum Digger would say that.

I believe the remaining scum is in the Rebel, Justin, Metro pool. Maybe Pancho, but he's much further down my list (although he's fooled me before).
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Justin on July 14, 2018, 04:24:36 PM
Vote: Eli

Sticking to my original vote.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 14, 2018, 04:29:30 PM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


 2 -- Powers (Metro, Eli)

2 -- Eli (Gooch, Justin)


Not Voting --  Powers, Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger, Kirk, Rebel


With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Kirk on July 15, 2018, 04:44:49 AM
Vote: Powers

I'm no less convinced about him today than I was before. Powers is obviously not think skinned, but Jack Bowser showed how petty and scheming he can be.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 08:00:30 AM
*sigh*

I guess if I want today to not be wasted I need to do this now rather than later.

I vigged Gates last night. You're welcome.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Kirk on July 15, 2018, 09:35:15 AM
Bullshit.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Kirk on July 15, 2018, 09:38:33 AM
*sigh*

I guess if I want today to not be wasted I need to do this now rather than later.

I vigged Gates last night. You're welcome.

Why didn't you kill anyone night 1?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 09:42:42 AM
Why didn't you kill anyone night 1?

Doesn't sound like that is his role.

To answer a question from yesterday. I was given the ability to check someone. I checked Kirk. It came back innocent.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Rebelicious on July 15, 2018, 11:28:38 AM
I don't buy Powers' deal with "Vigging Gates." Grasping at straws.

vote Powers
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 15, 2018, 11:31:03 AM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


4 -- Powers (Metro, Eli, Kirk, Rebel)

2 -- Eli (Gooch, Justin)


Not Voting --  Powers, Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 12:11:04 PM
I don't buy Powers' deal with "Vigging Gates." Grasping at straws.

vote Powers

if someone else will come forward saying they did it to prove him wrong I'll change my vote. Until then my vote stays.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 12:33:02 PM
I'm just saying it's a ballsy play to claim you did something when someone else in the game actually did it.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 03:33:23 PM
I am Frank Castle, The Punisher, Town Vig. I didn't kill anyone N1 because I didn't want to waste one of my shots when I was unsure of who I wanted to use it on.

If you want to proceed with a lynch of someone who has claimed a role that is clearly town, that is up to you. It would be clearly scum motivated/driven, so that should allow the town to narrow down who to go after next.

Vote Rebel

He was already on my radar and then he placed a vote after a town claim.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 15, 2018, 03:45:39 PM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


4 -- Powers (Metro, Eli, Kirk, Rebel)

2 -- Eli (Gooch, Justin)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 15, 2018, 05:47:22 PM
Anyone going to counter claim Powers? If not I see no reason not to believe him...
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 05:54:28 PM
Doesn't sound like that is his role.

To answer a question from yesterday. I was given the ability to check someone. I checked Kirk. It came back innocent.

When you say you were "given" the ability, do you mean from another player?  Or that your role was a 1-shot cop?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 06:20:29 PM
I was given the ability for a 1 time use.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 06:49:20 PM
I was given the ability for a 1 time use.

....by another player?  Meaning, did Player X use their night action to give you the 1-shot?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 07:01:31 PM
Yes. Didn't say who.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 07:08:16 PM
I find this very interesting.  To summarize, here is what you are claiming happened:

- Player X uses their ability N1 to give you a 1-shot cop (or similar ability)
- DURING the N1 phase, you are notified that you have been given this ability
- Still during the same night phase, you decide you want to use this ability on Kirk
- Finally at the end of the phase you are given a 'not guilty' (or the equivalent) on Kirk

All of that happened during one night phase?  I have a problem believing that for sure.  Not trying to mod the mod here, but I have never seen a player be able to give another player an ability which they are able to use immediately.  A far more common scenario has Player X give you the ability N1, which you are then able to use on N2.  For all this to have happened on N1......nah, I'm not buying it.

Unvote

Vote Gooch


Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 15, 2018, 07:24:14 PM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


4 -- Powers (Metro, Eli, Kirk, Rebel)

2 -- Eli (Gooch, Justin)

1 -- Gooch (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 08:11:24 PM
Well, looks like Eli didn't have to convince me.

I was given an action on N1 to use during the day and I used it.

unvote

Vote: Powers


Congratulations. You played yourself.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 08:17:39 PM
Ahh, it was a day cop ability.  I didn't think of that.  I really thought I caught you out on something there.

Unvote

Vote Rebel


Your OMGUS vote is noted however.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 08:20:01 PM
Note it, big boy.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 15, 2018, 08:20:58 PM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


5 -- Powers (Metro, Eli, Kirk, Rebel, Gooch)

1 -- Eli (Justin)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 08:38:47 PM
I know it's been a while since we played, but are you guys REALLY going to lynch a player who has claimed (without counter) a confirmed town role?  Because if so....damn.

In case I get hammered, here is my suspects list, in order of suspicion:

-Rebel/Metro/Justin (scum reads)
-Eli/Pancho (null reads)
-Kirk/Gooch/Digger (town reads)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 08:41:01 PM
You're right.

Unvote

Still didn't like that you came at me without considering a day action. But, it's a game.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 08:44:12 PM
Hey, what can I say?  The fact that it could've been a day action didn't occur to me, and I got excited.

While we're dialouging, what're your scum reads?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 15, 2018, 08:45:45 PM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


4 -- Powers (Metro, Eli, Kirk, Rebel)

1 -- Eli (Justin)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger, Gooch

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
   
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 08:47:18 PM
I have Eli in my scum reads but that's it. I know Kirk is town. I believe you are town. I don't get a scum vibe from Justin, though.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 15, 2018, 08:49:56 PM
You'd be making a bad read then.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 15, 2018, 08:55:12 PM
You'd be making a bad read then.

Outside of me, who're your other scum reads?  Why does my claim not give you pause?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Kirk on July 15, 2018, 09:08:31 PM
Why Gates?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Justin on July 15, 2018, 09:11:00 PM
I still feel it in my gut that Eli is scum.  I believe Powers and knowing the player he is, he wouldn't make the claim unless he had to.  I'm not sure what Metro thinks he has on Powers, but I believe it to erroneous. 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 15, 2018, 09:19:35 PM
My reads right now, without having a whole lot to back them up just my gut feeling, is as follows

Gooch/Kirk/Powers (scum reads)
Justin/Metro (null reads)
Rebel/Digger/Pancho (town reads)

Said from the start of this day that I still really suspect Kirk but I placed my vote where I did to try and get more information. What's the reasoning behind thinking I'm scum? Because of the early WIFOM assertion against Kirk? Seems pretty flimsy.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 09:26:44 PM
My reads right now, without having a whole lot to back them up just my gut feeling, is as follows

Gooch/Kirk/Powers (scum reads)
Justin/Metro (null reads)
Rebel/Digger/Pancho (town reads)

Said from the start of this day that I still really suspect Kirk but I placed my vote where I did to try and get more information. What's the reasoning behind thinking I'm scum? Because of the early WIFOM assertion against Kirk? Seems pretty flimsy.

So I clear Kirk with no opposition...but he's scum...Powers makes a claim that no one opposes...but he's still scum. There is a town player who can give out nightly gifts that won't throw a vote on any of the 3 of us...but we are your reads...this defies logic.

I guess I'll throw my vote back on the one I think is the scummiest. Your logic makes no sense.

Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 15, 2018, 09:31:29 PM
 
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


4 -- Powers (Metro, Eli, Kirk, Rebel)

2 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger
With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
   
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 15, 2018, 09:45:01 PM
Never said I'm certain of anything. Just what I think given what I've seen and read. You're looking at things from the point of view of someone who has been a part of these games on multiple occasions and has an understandings of what kind of different things can be done action wise on a day and night basis.

I'm looking at things from the perspective of a first time player who is piecing things together that seem to come together coincidentally. Not to mention I've already said if you're reading me as scum you're making a bad read.

But sure you go with me being the scummiest. That makes perfect sense.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 10:07:06 PM
You've really never played before?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Gooch on July 15, 2018, 10:07:35 PM
You've really never played before?

That's a sincere question with no jab in it at all.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 15, 2018, 10:36:49 PM
No lol I am exceptionally noobish at this game lol. This my mafia game cherry.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Justin on July 15, 2018, 10:54:13 PM
Still scum.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Metroll on July 16, 2018, 12:32:12 AM
Mobile... Itís a ballsy claim by PowPow and I could see one or two ways around it ++ Jon and Pancho havenít chimed in. For the moment though Iíll take it because I also have been feeling Eli and his 2nd Vote is a good spot to hit home on.

Unvote
Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 16, 2018, 12:34:24 AM

DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


3 -- Powers ( Eli, Kirk, Rebel)

3 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch, Metro)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
     
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Kirk on July 16, 2018, 01:09:18 AM
Unvote

My initial reaction was that Powers was trying to pull a fast one, but thinking longer about it makes that seem less likely. With Gates gone, Powers claiming vig is a high risk move. Sure, he might flush out the real vig but he'll die in the process. I'd be very surprised if the mafia had the numbers to sacrifice one of their own right after losing one. It's a huge risk for minimal gain.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Powers on July 16, 2018, 01:21:49 AM
Why Gates?

At the time I was 50/50 on Gates and Metro. I eventually settled on Gates for no real reason. It could've easily been Metro.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 16, 2018, 01:28:07 AM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


2 -- Powers ( Eli, Rebel)

3 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch, Metro)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)


Not Voting --  Pancho, Jon, Gravedigger, Kirk

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
     
[/quote]
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Eli on July 16, 2018, 07:32:20 AM
unvote

vote: Kirk

No reason to keep it on Powers at this point so ill put my vote back on Kirk. I know what Gooch says. I also donít buy it.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Kirk on July 16, 2018, 08:12:36 AM
My gut says Pancho and Digger are scum. Pancho's "vote" for Gates when he knew it wouldn't have any effect seems like a risk-free way to distance himself from him. Digger followed Gates' vote and didn't unvote after Gooch vouched for me. After Gates flipped scum, Digger made a flippant comment about voting the same way as Gates before going back into hiding.

Vote: Digger

Of the two, his play seems most suspect.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Jon on July 16, 2018, 09:57:29 AM
Sorry guys, was away at a Family reunion camping and am back now.

On a airplane right now so I kind of skimmed read things.

- Powers claimed with no counter claim. I believe him to be town.

I still didnít like Justinís response on Day 2 and his play hasnít changed my scum read on him.

Vote: Justin
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 16, 2018, 10:07:46 AM

DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Powers ( Rebel)

3 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch, Metro)

1 -- Rebel (Powers)

1 -- Kirk (Eli)

1 -- Gravedigger (Kirk)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

Not Voting --  Pancho, Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is at 12PM (Eastern Time) Monday.
     


Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: GM Pancho on July 16, 2018, 11:51:41 AM
Vote: Rebel

Sorry for the inactivity - hypocrite I know.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 3
Post by: Talon on July 16, 2018, 11:54:20 AM
DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Powers ( Rebel)

3 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch, Metro)

2 -- Rebel (Powers, Pancho)

1 -- Kirk (Eli)

1 -- Gravedigger (Kirk)

1 -- Justin (Jon)


Not Voting --  Gravedigger

With 10 Alive it takes 6 To Lynch

Deadline is in 5 minutes!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 3
Post by: Talon on July 16, 2018, 12:08:40 PM
 
(https://78.media.tumblr.com/ec83217a69ee51d3a261b190166265f6/tumblr_p4zsh61Kol1rm97r4o1_400.gif)
FINAL DAY 3 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Powers ( Rebel)

3 -- Eli (Justin, Gooch, Metro)

2 -- Rebel (Powers, Pancho)

1 -- Kirk (Eli)

1 -- Gravedigger (Kirk)

1 -- Justin (Jon)


Not Voting --  Gravedigger


 

NO LYNCH!



IT IS NOW NIGHT 3, YOU HAVE 36 HOURS TO SUBMIT YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS -- DEADLINE TO SUBMIT IS 11:59 PM TUESDAY .

 
 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 17, 2018, 01:11:35 PM

Another night in the city, and the scum is out again. BILLY RUSSO is determined to kill after missing out the night before..  He finds himself sitting on a floral couch in a small apartment in Hell's Kitchen where KAREN PAIGE pours him a cup of coffee.

 
"So Mr. Russo, tell me again, why is it that ANVIL operatives have turned up dead all around the city lately?"

"On the record, or off Ms. Paige?"

"..Whichever gets me the truth."

BILLY smirks and stands up to accept the cup of coffee, pacing as he waits for it to cool down.

"Well lets go off the record then Karen..  You see, my men have been working relentlessly to find an old friend of mine, Frank Castle..."

"..but Frank Castle has been dead for six months, we all know that."

"Do we?  Do YOU?  Because my sources tell me that New York's Favorite reporter is sitting on a big juicy story... that the PUNISHER is still alive and is out for some sort of revenge."

"..is he after you?.."

KAREN grows uneasy, realizing the mistake she made letting BILLY into her home.  She knew she had no way to reach out to Frank, but she did have her pistol in her purse.  She casually stood and moved towards her bag, leaning back against the table to attempt to find the gun without raising much suspicion, but the weapon was nowhere to be found.

"..Oh, Looking for this?"

BILLY says with a psychotic smile as he lifts a small pistol in his hand, dangling it in front of the terrified reporter.  In an instant she tries to run, but he raises the weapon and squeezes the trigger, shooting her in the back and leaving her for dead.  Without a trace of emotion, BILLY wipes his fingerprints from gun and drops it on the floor, leaving the apartment continuing his search for Frank.


(https://media.giphy.com/media/H5iOLz1c2bpvi/giphy.gif)
DEAD -  Pancho --- Karen Paige -  x1 Town Governor



IT IS NOW DAY 4 --- WITH 9 ALIVE IT TAKES 5 TO LYNCH!  --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM THURSDAY  (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 17, 2018, 01:26:06 PM
I believe we have a 3rd party with the Punisher coming in. I don't think that is a town role. We just haven't seen any action from them. Odds are this is a seasoned player who is waiting for more information to make their move.

I have no leanings on Rebel to scum or innocent, but I do feel like someone is trying to frame him as Pancho put a vote on him yesterday. So unless Rebel is outside of his mind as scum, killing Pancho would've been a poor play.

I still get a scum read from Eli and him being coached to say some of the stuff he's saying.

The gut instinct I have right now is on Jon. Jon threw a vote on Gates "to get the conversation started." Jon only threw a vote on Pancho who we now see was town. I think it's safe to say that Jon is one of the smartest players we have and even the subtle nuances of throwing a random vote on Gates would still, visibly, split himself from Gates.

I'm leaning on a vote for Eli or Jon, but I have absolutely no other information, just a gut instinct.

I believe that Powers and Kirk are town. Losing the town cop night one was rough.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 17, 2018, 01:35:02 PM
So I'm just going to throw out there that, prior to this last post, Gooch has been saying 100% that Kirk is town, and now it's just "I believe." I don't know if that's just me reading too much into the language Gooch is choosing, or if it's an unintentional crack in the foundation of the assertions he's been trying to make.

I will continue to say if you're reading me as scum, you're not making a correct read.

And I'll kick off the voting by putting mine on Gooch.

Vote: Gooch
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 17, 2018, 01:40:48 PM
(https://78.media.tumblr.com/30e9339768d2f88839f62b2b6fb4394d/tumblr_p1e99eSMpt1vdrfmro3_540.gif)

DAY 4 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Gooch ( Eli)
 


Not Voting --  Powers, Jon, Gravedigger, Justin, Kirk, Rebel, Gooch, Metro



With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM THURSDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 17, 2018, 01:45:27 PM
So I'm just going to throw out there that, prior to this last post, Gooch has been saying 100% that Kirk is town, and now it's just "I believe." I don't know if that's just me reading too much into the language Gooch is choosing, or if it's an unintentional crack in the foundation of the assertions he's been trying to make.

I will continue to say if you're reading me as scum, you're not making a correct read.

And I'll kick off the voting by putting mine on Gooch.

Vote: Gooch

I want to encourage everyone to vote for me. You'll be in for a great surprise.

You've tried to hollow out my claim that Kirk is town because of semantics. I still got the same result and believe it to be true. But, with how defensive you are with no proof on the contrary, I guess my vote will go to you.

Vote: Eli

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 17, 2018, 01:48:18 PM
DAY 4 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Gooch ( Eli)
 
1 -- Eli (Gooch)

Not Voting --  Powers, Jon, Gravedigger, Justin, Kirk, Rebel, Metro



With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM THURSDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 17, 2018, 01:51:20 PM
Put your vote on me but the one who will be surprised is you if you get 4 more votes.

You just got done talking about people and the subtle nuances of the game. I don't think it was just an innocent slip of the tongue with the change from "I know" to "I believe" in regards to kirk. And there is a difference, let me illustrate.

I believe that Kirk is scum.

I know that if this day's vote ends up with me being lynched, you'll be in for a surprise.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 17, 2018, 02:00:25 PM
I believe that Powers and Kirk are town. Losing the town cop night one was rough.

The sentence is structured based off of Powers first. I believe he's town. I don't know he's town. I know, from my response that Kirk is town. I think it's okay pertaining to English to tie the two together under the previous verb.

I won't be surprised if I get voted off, but I'm okay with it as well. So, feel free to lead a lynch mob. It'll suck for you the next day phase coming at me as hard as you have where I've cleared someone as town.

What have you contributed to the town's efforts?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 17, 2018, 02:05:14 PM
I'll go ahead and give a spoiler. I'm vanilla town. I lucked out and was given an action night 1 to use during the next day. That's how I got Kirk's read.

Voting me off you only lose a vanilla townie...but you also lose a vote for the town.

You've contributed nothing to this game except for disagreeing with everything I've said.

Feel free to start a bandwagon. Gather your evidence of semantics. I encourage 4 other people (who won't include Kirk or Powers) to throw a vote on me. You'll lose a town vote.

I still think you are being coached by someone and we just haven't figured out who.

Unless there is evidence given by another player to determine what I've said is incorrect. My vote is going to say on Eli. His vote is going to stay on me. The best bet is to probably bandwagon one or the other.

If it's me, that's cool. Enjoy the next day phase.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 17, 2018, 02:09:16 PM
Allegedly cleared someone as town. I could just as easily come out right now and say... welp Rebel is town. Furthermore, what has Rebel, Digger, Justin, Metro, Jon or Powers contributed as town?

I think you've done a masterful job at pointing fingers in a number of different directions, really. Anyone who has questioned you you've immediately turned around and said HE'S SCUM! Really, excellent job deflecting.

As for the phraseology and word choice, that word and there links the two together in one thought. "I believe that Powers AND Kirk are town"

Now you believe. Before you were certain.

People can vote with me, against me, or otherwise. I'm not going to encourage anything. Just pointing out things I've noticed and giving my own personal opinion on them. Vote whichever way you want to fellas.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 17, 2018, 02:12:15 PM
If it turns out we're both telling the truth about ourselves, and I know that I am, well we've really made a mess of things lol.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 17, 2018, 02:15:25 PM
Allegedly cleared someone as town. I could just as easily come out right now and say... welp Rebel is town. Furthermore, what has Rebel, Digger, Justin, Metro, Jon or Powers contributed as town?

I don't have to ask them. I asked you. I think you are scum.

Quote
I think you've done a masterful job at pointing fingers in a number of different directions, really. Anyone who has questioned you you've immediately turned around and said HE'S SCUM! Really, excellent job deflecting.

Again, the only time I've done this has been...well, you. To think I've done anything "masterful" is nothing but a compliment. For that I thank you.

Quote
As for the phraseology and word choice, that word and there links the two together in one thought. "I believe that Powers AND Kirk are town"

Weak.

Quote
Now you believe. Before you were certain.

Semantics? I'm still certain from what I was given.

Quote
People can vote with me, against me, or otherwise. I'm not going to encourage anything. Just pointing out things I've noticed and giving my own personal opinion on them. Vote whichever way you want to fellas.

So...a post with a bag full of nothing still. Cool.

(http://www.reactiongifs.com/r/2013/09/yawn1.gif)


If it turns out we're both telling the truth about ourselves, and I know that I am, well we've really made a mess of things lol.

If that is the case...you have a reason for not playing very well, it's your first game. I'm just not any good at Mafia sometimes. Hahahaha. (Glad you are here, playing and active.)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Powers on July 17, 2018, 02:51:24 PM
Allegedly cleared someone as town. I could just as easily come out right now and say... welp Rebel is town. Furthermore, what has Rebel, Digger, Justin, Metro, Jon or Powers contributed as town?


Umm....I night killed a member of the mafia? Is that not good enough?


Gooch, what do you mean that you think Punisher is a 3rd party? You think there is a Punisher role outside of my Frank Castle role?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 17, 2018, 03:06:40 PM
Umm....I night killed a member of the mafia? Is that not good enough?


Gooch, what do you mean that you think Punisher is a 3rd party? You think there is a Punisher role outside of my Frank Castle role?

Now that you say that. No. After a quick Google search I now see that Frank Castle is Punisher...so...I now don't think there is a 3rd party and I do realize I should probably do research on a game I'm playing.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Metroll on July 17, 2018, 03:10:16 PM
You had my vote Gooch until I turned to page 4 ...

As is Vote: Eli he's only furthered my belief so far this day phase that he is mafia.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Jon on July 17, 2018, 03:13:16 PM
I don't disagree that their definitely could be a 3rd Party in this game, but no evidence in the write ups suggest as such and it's definitely not Frank Castle.

The whole Eli and Gooch back and forth screams more town v town then anything else... as they are just purely finger pointing with no real substance in their accusations. But if anyone is scum out of them, my bet is Eli.

And it's because of his attachment to Justin. Hear me out here.

I called out the inactive Day 1 posters, which Justin was apart of.

With Kirk already having two votes... Justin says this.

I understand your point on this, but don't think Powers would really do it.

I'm inclined to think Eli and Kirk are in cahoots and they are trying to appear on opposite ends of the spectrum.

Vote: Eli

When questioned on why if he thought both were in cahoots, would he vote Eli instead of being a 3rd vote on Kirk (who turns out to be presumably found town by Gooch in a Day Cop role given to him). He said this...   

Because I don't think Pancho will stick with his vote which leaves only Eli voting for Kirk and he's going to stick his vote there to make him look less suspect.

This just didn't make any sense to me. So here is my case on the matter.

Justin and Eli have not seen eye to eye with each other since Day 2 pretty much. If I'm right on Justin being scum, then he knows by voting Kirk, it's a vote on a townie (if we believe Gooch and that his result is accurate). So he instead turns to his scummate Eli. By driving a wedge between them early, it gives off a nice separation technique. They didn't account for losing Gates so soon though. But still allows the survivor of the two to use all the gameplay posting to try and show their township.

Maybe I'm reaching here. Maybe not.

I do think Justin is scum though. 

Vote: Justi

   
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Jon on July 17, 2018, 03:13:55 PM
In case that didn't count for forgetting the "n".

Unvote

Vote: Justin

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Justin on July 17, 2018, 03:24:51 PM
Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Metroll on July 17, 2018, 03:26:35 PM
Jon's town v. town comment got me thinking. Day 2 Gooch got a magic day cop. Day 3 we didn't see anything. Not ruling out that it was a 1 shot or people are holding their cards close to their chest but a thought running through my mind. Could it not be town v. town but mafia v. mafia. A mafia person calling a town person town is easy. I've got massive scum vibes from Eli. And to Jon's point about the finger pointing with nothing but substance is actually decent mafia play to appear active and in Eli's words "contribute as town".

Not enough to get my vote yet but something worth considering.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 17, 2018, 03:28:22 PM
Just out of curiosity, because I'm new at this game and I'm trying to at least begin to pick up how things are put together, if you believe that Justin and I are in cahoots so to speak (even though earlier you had said you think Gooch and I going back and forth is town v town) in the scenario you presented, why would you put your vote on Justin? I may be an idiot but wouldn't it be more logical to put your vote on the person that the votes are obviously starting to go in the direction of? I've already picked up Gooch and Metro's vote. You putting yours on me would put me at 3, and only in need of 2 more with what 5 left available?

Just seems like Justin is the odd choice to put a vote on if you're looking for more information.

If Justin doesn't keep his vote on me this round, though, I suppose that might add support to that claim? I don't know. Just confused as to why you'd go that direction.

And as I was about to post that I see Justin just put his vote on me again.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 17, 2018, 03:32:52 PM
DAY 4 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Gooch ( Eli)
 
3 -- Eli (Gooch, Metro, Justin)

1 -- Justin (Jon)

Not Voting --  Powers, Gravedigger, Kirk, Rebel



With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM THURSDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Jon on July 17, 2018, 03:33:00 PM
Just out of curiosity, because I'm new at this game and I'm trying to at least begin to pick up how things are put together, if you believe that Justin and I are in cahoots so to speak (even though earlier you had said you think Gooch and I going back and forth is town v town) in the scenario you presented, why would you put your vote on Justin? I may be an idiot but wouldn't it be more logical to put your vote on the person that the votes are obviously starting to go in the direction of? I've already picked up Gooch and Metro's vote. You putting yours on me would put me at 3, and only in need of 2 more with what 5 left available?

Just seems like Justin is the odd choice to put a vote on if you're looking for more information.

If Justin doesn't keep his vote on me this round, though, I suppose that might add support to that claim? I don't know. Just confused as to why you'd go that direction.

And as I was about to post that I see Justin just put his vote on me again.

I don't necessarily think you are scum. But my reaction to Justin being scum was based on his Day 2 post but as I was typing, it sparked a thought.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Justin on July 17, 2018, 03:35:53 PM
I don't disagree that their definitely could be a 3rd Party in this game, but no evidence in the write ups suggest as such and it's definitely not Frank Castle.

The whole Eli and Gooch back and forth screams more town v town then anything else... as they are just purely finger pointing with no real substance in their accusations. But if anyone is scum out of them, my bet is Eli.

And it's because of his attachment to Justin. Hear me out here.

I called out the inactive Day 1 posters, which Justin was apart of.

With Kirk already having two votes... Justin says this.

When questioned on why if he thought both were in cahoots, would he vote Eli instead of being a 3rd vote on Kirk (who turns out to be presumably found town by Gooch in a Day Cop role given to him). He said this...   

This just didn't make any sense to me. So here is my case on the matter.

Justin and Eli have not seen eye to eye with each other since Day 2 pretty much. If I'm right on Justin being scum, then he knows by voting Kirk, it's a vote on a townie (if we believe Gooch and that his result is accurate). So he instead turns to his scummate Eli. By driving a wedge between them early, it gives off a nice separation technique. They didn't account for losing Gates so soon though. But still allows the survivor of the two to use all the gameplay posting to try and show their township.

Maybe I'm reaching here. Maybe not.

I do think Justin is scum though. 

Vote: Justi

 

You're reaching.  Eli's game play the entire time has given nothing but scum vibes to me.  Hence my vote has remained on him.  I believe he is the best vote.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Powers on July 17, 2018, 03:58:02 PM
Eli reads to me as newb town more than anything. Although I do need to reread Jons post and percolate on it some more.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 17, 2018, 04:06:12 PM
Could kiss you on the mouth right now Powers but that would probably make people think I'm scummier.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Metroll on July 17, 2018, 04:27:37 PM
Could kiss you on the mouth right now Powers but that would probably make people think I'm scummier.

Not kissing Pow-Pow but this post ... GAWD IS IT SCUMMY!!!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Kirk on July 17, 2018, 07:50:52 PM
Jon has done the exact same thing he's accused Justin of in the post where he voted for Justin. If Justin is worth a vote for doing it, why not Jon?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Kirk on July 17, 2018, 07:59:20 PM
So Powers is the punisher, he thinks Rebel/Metro/Justin are scum, he wanted to lynch Rebel, we didn't lynch anyone and yet he didn't kill anyone last night. I'm having a tough time buying that and the fact that the mafia didn't go after him.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Jon on July 17, 2018, 08:25:29 PM
Jon has done the exact same thing he's accused Justin of in the post where he voted for Justin. If Justin is worth a vote for doing it, why not Jon?

Then you didn't read the post accurately.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Powers on July 17, 2018, 08:34:05 PM
So Powers is the punisher, he thinks Rebel/Metro/Justin are scum, he wanted to lynch Rebel, we didn't lynch anyone and yet he didn't kill anyone last night. I'm having a tough time buying that and the fact that the mafia didn't go after him.

I can't speak to why nobody went after me. I can say that I didn't kill last night because I was not able to as a result of how my role works.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Kirk on July 17, 2018, 09:25:51 PM
Then you didn't read the post accurately.

Justin said that Eli and I were in cahoots and voted for Eli despite there being more votes on me - scummy according to you.

You said Justin and Eli are in cahoots but voted for Justin despite there being more votes on ELi - not scummy?

It's exactly the same thing.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Jon on July 17, 2018, 09:30:47 PM
Justin said that Eli and I were in cahoots and voted for Eli despite there being more votes on me - scummy according to you.

You said Justin and Eli are in cahoots but voted for Justin despite there being more votes on ELi - not scummy?

It's exactly the same thing.

I said Gooch and Eli is most likely town.

As I was typing my case on Justin, I noticed that there is potential there and thought it was interesting, so I noted it.

Don't necessarily think Eli is scum, but I would probably be interested in him if Justin flips scum.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Powers on July 17, 2018, 09:44:11 PM
I can get behind a Justin lynch.

Vote Justin
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 17, 2018, 09:51:35 PM
DAY 4 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Gooch ( Eli)
 
3 -- Eli (Gooch, Metro, Justin)

2 -- Justin (Jon, Powers)

Not Voting -- Gravedigger, Kirk, Rebel



With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM THURSDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Kirk on July 18, 2018, 05:45:42 AM
I want to vote Digger because he's still hiding and I think what he has said so far has been scummy as hell. I don't want to split the votes further considering we've managed to achieve nothing in day phases so far so I suppose my choice is between Eli, Justin and Gooch. I don't see Eli as scum, mainly because I'm suspicious of all three players currently voting for him. I don't think Jon's case against Justin is particularly strong and I find it curious that Powers has abandoned his vote for Rebel from yesterday to follow Jon on this. I could get behind a Gooch vote because I just get the vibe that he's cleared me to gain town cred.

Feel free to start a bandwagon. Gather your evidence of semantics. I encourage 4 other people (who won't include Kirk or Powers) to throw a vote on me. You'll lose a town vote.

That rubbed me the wrong way but, as Powers said, I get more of a feeling of two townies fighting each other while the mafia sit back and watch.

Powers, you were suspicious enough of Rebel yesterday to vote for him but today you haven't mentioned him at all. Pancho also voted for him and now Pancho is dead. What convinced you to give up on Rebel?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Powers on July 18, 2018, 12:35:40 PM
I've gained zero traction on a Rebel lynch. Justin is on my scum list as well (along with Metro) and that has more of a chance at getting done.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 18, 2018, 02:32:45 PM
I have nothing to add that I haven't said. I feel comfortable with my vote.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Metroll on July 18, 2018, 04:30:38 PM
I have nothing to add that I haven't said. I feel comfortable with my vote.

So based on this post it's either Eli or no lynch ... I almost like my vote less now but I want Gravedigger/Rebel to chime in.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Kirk on July 18, 2018, 06:36:19 PM
Vote: Justin

We need to lynch someone at some point. Let's see where this gets us.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 18, 2018, 07:40:36 PM
DAY 4 VOTE COUNT


1 -- Gooch ( Eli)
 
3 -- Eli (Gooch, Metro, Justin)

3 -- Justin (Jon, Powers, Kirk)

Not Voting -- Gravedigger, Rebel



With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM THURSDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 18, 2018, 07:45:39 PM
The only one I'm willing to clear right now is Powers, considering no one even attempted to counter his Frank Castle claim.

I'm also willing to go for a Justin lynch.

Vote: Justin
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 18, 2018, 09:28:37 PM
Fuck it. My vote isnít doing anything and he has constantly voted against me.

unvote

Vote: Justin
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 18, 2018, 10:57:50 PM
Fuck it. My vote isnít doing anything and he has constantly voted against me.

unvote

Vote: Justin


THAT'S A LYNCH!



FINAL DAY 4 VOTE COUNT

 
3 -- Eli (Gooch, Metro, Justin)

5 -- Justin (Jon, Powers, Kirk, Digger, Eli)

Not Voting -- Rebel



(http://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338825.jpg)
LYNCHED - JUSTIN --- Sarah Lieberman -- Vanilla Townie

IT IS NOW NIGHT 4, YOU HAVE UNTIL 11 AM FRIDAY TO SUBMIT NIGHT ACTIONS
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: Talon on July 19, 2018, 12:21:33 PM
"Let's end this Bill... Name the time and place, I'll be there."

"How about we meet at your painted ponies Frankie-boy,  at Midnight..."

LATER THAT NIGHT

FRANK CASTLE approaches the same Carousel that he took his children too the day of their gruesome murder.  He approaches cautiously, knowing that BILLY RUSSO would be there waiting...

CLACK-BANG! CLACK-BANG!

Gunshots ring out as FRANK is struck in the chest by a bullet.  He collapses to the ground hard, but gasps for air as he looks down at his bulletproof vest.  He growls and comes up in a fury!

RUSSO!!! FACE ME!!! I'M GONNA WATCH YOU DIE BILL!!!!!   RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!

In a flash he rushes towards BILLY and the two exchange blows.  Punches, kicks... total hand to hand combat, but BILLY has a trick up his sleeve.  FRANK smashes him back first into the carousel, ready to bash his brains in, but suddenly he is stopped as RUSSO'S hidden knife jets from its wrist holster and pierce through FRANK'S body armor.. 

"Surprise Frankie... ...look at you... The freakin' Punisher?  ...Your Pathetic!"

BILLY drops his blade and grins sadistically as he walks away, leaving FRANK to die.



DEAD --- ??? --- FRANK CASTLE --- .....


"Jesus Frank! ....Hold on brother, I'm not going to let you go like this."



CURTIS HOYLE appears, running out of the shadows, medical bag in hand... he works all night to patch up and heal FRANK keeping him alive!



IT IS NOW DAY 5 --- WITH 8 ALIVE IT TAKES 5 TO LYNCH!  --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM SATURDAY  (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 19, 2018, 12:27:29 PM
So, whoever our doctor is protected Powers? Would that be a safe conclusion?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 4
Post by: GM Powers on July 19, 2018, 12:32:31 PM
And they must have a strongman - that's how they got through my vest.

PLEASE tell me that I was watched last night.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 4
Post by: GM Metroll on July 19, 2018, 01:11:28 PM
And they must have a strongman - that's how they got through my vest.

PLEASE tell me that I was watched last night.

In the absence of this. Vote: Digger

Question: Eli, are you the mafia Godfather?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 4
Post by: GM Gooch on July 19, 2018, 01:26:24 PM
I saw Metro's post and was curious as to what Digger has said this game...and it totals 5 posts...5. But, they are interesting...

Vote: Eli

Welcome to Mafia..

Interesting. Early subtle splitting between himself and Eli? I still believe Eli to be a mafia read. Digger and Eli could be who we are looking at.


It feels way too obvious, like we're being hit over the head with it... Not buying the "obvious = scum" theory...

Vote: Kirk

As for my inactivity, anyone who's been in a game with me knows I'm spotty at best when it comes to posting...

Not entirely true. I've played plenty of games with you in the past with plenty of interaction. I never thought, "Man, I wish Digger was on more." I always thought you were an active player.

Well, now I feel a bit stupid having voted the same as Mafia....

This seems like a comment pushed too hard. He teamed with Gates to try to run a wagon and it fell off. Gates dies and he thinks he has to save face?

Anyone going to counter claim Powers? If not I see no reason not to believe him...

The only one I'm willing to clear right now is Powers, considering no one even attempted to counter his Frank Castle claim.

I'm also willing to go for a Justin lynch.

Vote: Justin

The second time he mentions no one countering Powers. Almost like he's making sure that the kill for the night action is going to be a sure shot.

VOTE: Digger
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 4
Post by: Talon on July 19, 2018, 01:32:27 PM
(https://d1gbp99v447ls8.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/01010635/micro-2.gif)
DAY 5 VOTE COUNT


2 -- Gravedigger (Gooch, Metro)


Not Voting -- Gravedigger, Rebel, Jon, Powers, Kirk, Eli



With 8 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM SATURDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 19, 2018, 01:44:51 PM
I also HATED Digger's "well I feel stupid..." post.  I don't want to throw a 3rd vote on him this early in the phase, but consider this an 'intent to vote' if nothing changes during this day.

Am I really reading Eli that poorly?  I'm admittedly second and third guessing my read on him, but I am just not seeing what y'all are seeing.

I want to hear from Rebel.  Something.  Anything.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: Talon on July 19, 2018, 02:04:24 PM
I want to hear from Rebel.  Something.  Anything.

Me too
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 19, 2018, 02:13:03 PM
We can do a run down memory lane of Rebel's contributions to the game. This list doesn't include his introductory "What's this?" post.

So let's begin. 

That's just rude.

I'm here for the showwww.

...

Iím inclined to check on Gates. I find it slightly odd that as soon as Kirk throws out his lame ďnobody talks in day one so theyíre scum!Ē post that he immediately comes on and says he doesnít remember where the Mafia forum is?

Interesting.

I don't buy Powers' deal with "Vigging Gates." Grasping at straws.

vote Powers

And that concludes our posts from GM Rebel.

♪ ♫ Leave the memories alone... ♫ ♪

I don't like these posts, but I do feel confident in a vote for either Eli or Digger today.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 19, 2018, 02:43:36 PM
I got serious scum vibes (and I still have them) from those posts....however his absence has thrown me.  He is clearly not active enough to be Billy Russo.  I dunno anymore.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 4
Post by: GM Eli on July 19, 2018, 02:55:34 PM

Question: Eli, are you the mafia Godfather?

No. I am not the Mafia Godfather. I am also not any other role of mafia either.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 19, 2018, 03:00:16 PM
Valid point. His profile on the boards says his last visit was "July 17, 2018, 01:53:00 PM"

That means he missed the entire night action, unless he's only using the scum boards to make comments and that's why he hasn't been modkilled for inactivity.

I think I know what just happened in the previous posts. I'm looking forward to the response that is given.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 19, 2018, 04:15:50 PM
Hmmm...

I would venture to say that Rebel is most likely inactive town. The fact the MOD would post that he would also like to see activity from him helps me make that connection.

Gooch does have a point, he could be active in the mafia board offsite only. Who knows?

Digger is gonna have to show me something this day phase, because I agree with Metro and Gooch. He appears a bit off... then again I thought the same with Justin and was obviously wrong.

Iím definitely leaning towards Eli has town now because of the Justin flip.

Kirk and Metro... honestly havenít got a read on them one way or the other. Both are good enough players to give me reasonably alarm though.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Rebelicious on July 19, 2018, 04:37:57 PM
It's true ... I've been prodded.

The only gut read I've had, at the beginning of the game, was Gates ... and that proved to be an incorrect gig. Meanwhile, I've been inactive -- no scum board here. Just simply inactive because I'm not much in the routine of checking out the ESPN boards much since my hiatus.

vote Digger

The whole "I can't get a vote for X candidate to make it look like my target isn't Justin isn't working ... let's vote Justin now because he's voting for me!" schtick doesn't play well with me.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 19, 2018, 04:40:53 PM
Justin didn't vote for me, Reb...

As for the rest, I've got nothing. No informative role, only night action occurs if I'm targeted. All I can say is I'm town.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: Talon on July 19, 2018, 04:41:25 PM
 
DAY 5 VOTE COUNT


3 -- Gravedigger (Gooch, Metro, Rebel)


Not Voting -- Gravedigger, Jon, Powers, Kirk, Eli



With 8 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM SATURDAY  (EASTERN TIME)

 
 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 19, 2018, 04:43:04 PM
Justin didn't vote for me, Reb...

As for the rest, I've got nothing. No informative role, only night action occurs if I'm targeted. All I can say is I'm town.

We were not looking for role information from you Digger. But do you have any reads, any thoughts? Anything to contribute at all?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 19, 2018, 04:50:27 PM
It's true ... I've been prodded.

The only gut read I've had, at the beginning of the game, was Gates ... and that proved to be an incorrect gig. Meanwhile, I've been inactive -- no scum board here. Just simply inactive because I'm not much in the routine of checking out the ESPN boards much since my hiatus.

vote Digger

The whole "I can't get a vote for X candidate to make it look like my target isn't Justin isn't working ... let's vote Justin now because he's voting for me!" schtick doesn't play well with me.


Uhh....Gates was scum bro.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 19, 2018, 04:56:05 PM

Uhh....Gates was scum bro.

Didnít even see that. Think it was an intentional slip?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Rebelicious on July 19, 2018, 05:37:35 PM
Didnít even see that. Think it was an intentional slip?

It wasn't. It was supposed to say "correct."
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Metroll on July 19, 2018, 08:04:26 PM
Oxymoron much Jon. I like Rebel and Digger - you all can count on my vote either way.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 19, 2018, 08:36:12 PM
Metro, have you detected anything else?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Metroll on July 19, 2018, 08:46:04 PM
Metro, have you detected anything else?

Not a detector but I know that Eli is not Billy Russo so figured I'd ask him if he was the Godfather. Otherwise - he's probably not mafia (4 mafia would be a massive stretch in a game this size).
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Kirk on July 19, 2018, 09:24:49 PM
Are we all just assuming that Jon is town? He's playing this calm, voice of reason role that everyone seems to be going along with but he hasn't done anything to earn the trust.

Rebel is clearly not paying any attention to the game whatsoever, which makes me think he's doing it on purpose. Even if you were just skimming the thread, you wouldn't produce the stream of complete nonsense that Rebel has come out with since being "prodded."

I've been waiting to lynch Digger for the last couple of days, but I'm holding off so we can get some more conversation here. Am I the only one concerned about Jon's play? The fact that the mafia didn't go straight for Powers when he revealed his role makes me think they have a Jon/Metro caliber player on their team.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 19, 2018, 11:16:17 PM
I'll throw this out there, but I don't think my fate is going to change...

I'm looking at Jon, Kirk, and Eli as scum candidates. I'd say two of the three are scum. Going off of gut feeling, not anything else. Other than that I'd say there's an outside chance Metro is scum, but I think it's two of the other guys.

But I don't expect to survive, so it most likely won't matter. And I'm a town PGO if that helps anyone decide.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 20, 2018, 12:04:53 AM
Not a detector but I know that Eli is not Billy Russo so figured I'd ask him if he was the Godfather. Otherwise - he's probably not mafia (4 mafia would be a massive stretch in a game this size).

If he is The Godfather....do you expect him to admit it or something?


Are we all just assuming that Jon is town? He's playing this calm, voice of reason role that everyone seems to be going along with but he hasn't done anything to earn the trust.

Agreed.


I'll throw this out there, but I don't think my fate is going to change...

I'm looking at Jon, Kirk, and Eli as scum candidates. I'd say two of the three are scum. Going off of gut feeling, not anything else. Other than that I'd say there's an outside chance Metro is scum, but I think it's two of the other guys.

But I don't expect to survive, so it most likely won't matter. And I'm a town PGO if that helps anyone decide.


Super convenient claim. If you manage to survive the day phase, it scares away potential night inquiries.


Either there is a lack of night actions, or people are afraid of speaking out.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 20, 2018, 12:09:04 AM
It may be convenient, but it's also true. It will be shown when I flip after being lynched.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 20, 2018, 12:57:48 AM
Why didn't you insinuate you had some sort of strong pro-town night role? One that would've drawn scum to target you?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 20, 2018, 06:29:29 AM
Didn't think of it. Good idea, though. Only throwing it out there now because bit doesn't look good for me.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Metroll on July 20, 2018, 11:39:04 AM
If he is The Godfather....do you expect him to admit it or something?

No - but it never hurts to ask, right?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Eli on July 20, 2018, 12:03:53 PM
I don't believe Digger is scum and I won't be voting for him. I'm going to continue to stick with my initial vote unless someone has something more to implicate others.

Vote: Kirk
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 20, 2018, 12:06:57 PM
Kirk is town.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: Talon on July 20, 2018, 12:08:50 PM
DAY 5 VOTE COUNT


3 -- Gravedigger (Gooch, Metro, Rebel)

1 -- Kirk (Eli)

Not Voting -- Gravedigger, Jon, Powers, Kirk



With 8 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM SATURDAY  (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 20, 2018, 04:02:29 PM
Kirk is town.

Just curious Gooch. We understand you got a day cop role, but why are we to believe it was 100% accurate?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 20, 2018, 04:39:42 PM
Has anyone else been gifted anything?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 20, 2018, 04:59:55 PM
After rereading my post, I found out that I was given the 1 day cop because my partner had been killed. It wasn't someone that was giving out gifts. I don't watch the show, but apparently the characters were close. I used my day cop on Kirk and I have no reason to believe it would be tainted.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Powers on July 20, 2018, 10:26:16 PM
Vote Digger


Gooch, what character are you?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 20, 2018, 10:28:49 PM
Sam Stein
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 20, 2018, 10:31:01 PM
Vote: Eli

I'll throw out a final vote...
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Kirk on July 20, 2018, 11:20:52 PM
After rereading my post, I found out that I was given the 1 day cop because my partner had been killed. It wasn't someone that was giving out gifts. I don't watch the show, but apparently the characters were close. I used my day cop on Kirk and I have no reason to believe it would be tainted.

Vote: Gooch

I hate this. Any time someone changes their story about something like this is a huge red flag for me.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 20, 2018, 11:31:18 PM
The character claim by Gooch does checkout as Sam Stein was a partner of Dinah Madani according to the Marvelwiki.

Unless we are to believe Gooch long conned us or that if heís scum, he knows the Punisher Universe well enough to make a bold safe claim early in the game.

I donít know, that seems a bit out of Goochís level of play IMO.

Iím actually going to believe his claim but not believe his result. While reading up on Stein, his character used false information.

Vote: Kirk
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 21, 2018, 12:05:05 AM
The character claim by Gooch does checkout as Sam Stein was a partner of Dinah Madani according to the Marvelwiki.

Unless we are to believe Gooch long conned us or that if heís scum, he knows the Punisher Universe well enough to make a bold safe claim early in the game.

I donít know, that seems a bit out of Goochís level of play IMO.

Iím actually going to believe his claim but not believe his result. While reading up on Stein, his character used false information.

Vote: Kirk

You're not wrong about me but ouch anyways. That one stung a little bit.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Kirk on July 21, 2018, 12:08:36 AM
The character claim by Gooch does checkout as Sam Stein was a partner of Dinah Madani according to the Marvelwiki.

Unless we are to believe Gooch long conned us or that if heís scum, he knows the Punisher Universe well enough to make a bold safe claim early in the game.

I donít know, that seems a bit out of Goochís level of play IMO.

Iím actually going to believe his claim but not believe his result. While reading up on Stein, his character used false information.

Vote: Kirk

Jon outing himself. I think Gooch did play the long con and was fed the character information (by Jon). Jon knows that the mafia don't play by themselves but then makes the above post as if Gooch would have to come up with everything on his own. Gooch made a play to gain significant town cred, then he had to elaborate on it and suggested his role was gifted to him and now he suddenly realizes it was the result of another player's death. Sounds like nonsense to me.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 21, 2018, 12:11:18 AM
Jon outing himself. I think Gooch did play the long con and was fed the character information (by Jon). Jon knows that the mafia don't play by themselves but then makes the above post as if Gooch would have to come up with everything on his own. Gooch made a play to gain significant town cred, then he had to elaborate on it and suggested his role was gifted to him and now he suddenly realizes it was the result of another player's death. Sounds like nonsense to me.

Impressive story...and pretty convincing...but I just made a bad play and didn't read. I am town. I used my day cop ability and used it on Kirk and it came back innocent.

Since we are getting nowhere, if you guys want a quick lunch, go for a lynch on me. I'm vanilla. The only thing Ive done this game is luck out to be able to clear someone. Past that I've just tried to stay active.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 21, 2018, 12:12:02 AM
Jon outing himself. I think Gooch did play the long con and was fed the character information (by Jon). Jon knows that the mafia don't play by themselves but then makes the above post as if Gooch would have to come up with everything on his own. Gooch made a play to gain significant town cred, then he had to elaborate on it and suggested his role was gifted to him and now he suddenly realizes it was the result of another player's death. Sounds like nonsense to me.

You're right... that does sound like nonsense.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: Talon on July 21, 2018, 01:52:45 AM
 
DAY 5 VOTE COUNT


4 -- Gravedigger (Gooch, Metro, Rebel, Powers)

2 -- Kirk (Eli, Jon)

1 -- Eli (Gravedigger)

1 -- Gooch (Kirk)

Not Voting -- 



With 8 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch --- DEADLINE IS 1:00 PM SATURDAY  (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Jon on July 21, 2018, 12:53:33 PM
Not a fan of this, but at this stage a no lynch does nothing for us.

Unvote

Vote: Digger
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 5
Post by: Talon on July 21, 2018, 04:23:48 PM
After this post...

Not a fan of this, but at this stage a no lynch does nothing for us.

Unvote

Vote: Digger


We have a LYNCH!!!!


 
FINAL DAY 5 VOTE COUNT


5 -- Gravedigger (Gooch, Metro, Rebel, Powers, Jon)

1 -- Kirk (Eli)

1 -- Eli (Gravedigger)

1 -- Gooch (Kirk)

Not Voting -- 


(https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/villains/images/6/6e/LewisWilson.PNG/revision/latest?cb=20171122173921)
DEAD --- Gravedigger -- Lewis Wilson -- Town Paranoid Gun Owner



IT IS NOW NIGHT 5, YOU HAVE UNTIL 12 NOON SUNDAY TO SUBMIT NIGHT ACTIONS

 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 5
Post by: GM Gravedigger on July 21, 2018, 04:38:23 PM
BAH!!!!!!!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: Talon on July 21, 2018, 08:14:45 PM
BILLY RUSSO sits in the dark at the bedside of KIRK  who is sleeping, unaware of the trespasser in his home.   BILLY slowly approaches the bed and covers his head with a pillow before burring his gun into the cushion and pulling the trigger...

It didn't have to be this way... you just chose the wrong side.   ...I will not be brought down by people who are supposed to be my friends.

...with that he slips back into the night, leaving KIRK dead.

(https://i1.wp.com/78.media.tumblr.com/c1624e9351708b4d1c8aa647f9d71461/tumblr_p45pirmGMN1roxniio1_400.gif?w=605&ssl=1)
DEAD --- Kirk --- CURTIS HOYLE --- TOWN DOCTOR



IT IS NOW DAY 6 --- WITH 6 ALIVE IT TAKES 4 TO LYNCH!  --- DEADLINE IS 8:00 PM MONDAY  (EASTERN TIME)


PLAYER LIST - Powers,  Jon, Gooch, Rebel, Eli, Metro
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Metroll on July 21, 2018, 09:32:09 PM
Vote:Rebel
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Gooch on July 21, 2018, 09:38:29 PM
Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 21, 2018, 10:15:20 PM
I don't get these votes without any substance.

Let me try and paraphrase what has actually been happening.

Day 1: Jokes and Pancho/Powers back and forth. No lynch.

Night 1: T Bone (Dinah Madani - Town Cop) dies.

Day 2: Inactives called out by me, Powers and Kirk leading vote getters as we go to another no lynch.

Night 2: Kirk (Town Doctor) appears to have self-protected to avoid a kill? Then Powers kills Gates (scum).

Day 3: Powers nears a lynch and is forced to claim, saving himself. Gooch claims he was a Day Cop for one time use and calls Kirk town. Afterwards, votes get spread super thin with Eli receiving the most votes.

Night 3: Pancho (Town Govy) is killed.

Day 4: Eli and Gooch do a back and forth thing that lasts quite a few posts. I make my case on Justin. We end up lynching Justin, who was Town Vanilla.

Night 4: According to Powers, scum must have used some strongman kill to get to him, but Kirk protected him that night and was able to revive him.

Day 5: Rebel is apparently "prodded" and immediately shows up to post, only to disappear again. Digger claims PGO, while Powers questions why he would do that as he would want scum to target him at night. I hammer him right before deadline, he flips, Town PGO.

Night 5: Kirk (Town Doc) is killed.



So someone correct me if I missed anything that should be brought back on the table. But the one thing that sticks out to me is the Day 4 argument between Gooch and Eli. First, Eli has brought up on multiple occasions how "new" he is to this game. Almost has if it's impossible to be scum on his first game. He was on Kirk, Day 1 and 2 (Kirk happened to be a Night 2 target. He was on Kirk again last day phase, when Kirk died. Since that Gooch and Eli exchange... Eli has become very quiet. To me, he's attempting at being active enough to not go unnoticed, but careful to keep out of the discussion. Eli is our guy IMO.

Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 22, 2018, 02:20:37 AM
First off, we are at MYLO.  So all y'all need to calm down with the voting for now.

Second, I propose a mass claim, popcorn style.  I nominate Metro.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Eli on July 22, 2018, 07:06:35 AM
On mobile right now

To answer the question of why Iíve been quiet Iíve been away at the Casino since Thursday night so I havenít been all that active anywhere.

Also, I was wrong about Kirk have nothing that makes me really point a finger at anyone else but my belief is that Gooch is either mafia hard selling that Kirk was town to cover himself, or that heís telling the truth about his one shot ability or whatever. Because I was wrong about Kirk, Iíll lean toward Gooch telling the truth.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 22, 2018, 02:07:05 PM
Shit....Eli really is scum, isn't he?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 22, 2018, 02:08:57 PM
Shit....Eli really is scum, isn't he?

I believe he is. Either he and Metro or he and Rebel.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: Talon on July 22, 2018, 03:11:26 PM
(https://78.media.tumblr.com/a2edcc86961f37d590155ac83f5f3674/tumblr_p25ji4411u1vti6y9o1_540.gif)
DAY 6 VOTE COUNT

1 -- Rebel -- (Metro)

2 -- Eli -- (Gooch, Jon)


Not Voting --  Powers, Rebel, Eli



WITH 6 ALIVE IT TAKES 4 TO LYNCH!  --- DEADLINE IS 8:00 PM MONDAY  (EASTERN TIME)
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 22, 2018, 03:20:19 PM
I believe he is. Either he and Metro or he and Rebel.

I'm honestly pretty worried about you too at this point.  You have coasted this game as the 'voice of reason' for the town, with very little suspicion placed upon you.  It is not out of the realm of possibility that you are simply playing a MVP worthy scum game right now.

Forget that I nominated Metro (who is conveniently avoiding this thread today) above.  I'd like for you to claim please. 
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 22, 2018, 03:40:20 PM
Even thought I hate claims, at this point, they do help us out. And I understand your concern about me, as I would be concerned of you as well had we not known you you were.

I am Rafael "Rafi" Hernandez and I'm just a vanilla. However, I did have a theory about my role after Gooch outed his information rather then our initial thought of he was given his Town Cop ability by another player.

I'm not sure if it was a 50/50 shot between who got the Town Cop after T-Bone was night killed, but I wonder if Gooch had died, I would have gained an ability somehow.



 


Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Eli on July 22, 2018, 03:47:57 PM
I go to the casino so now I'm scum? Lmao.

Or is it because I admitted I was wrong about Kirk?

Tbh I think you're reaching but I'll say what I've said the last few votes. Go ahead. Vote for me and cost yourselves.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 22, 2018, 03:59:33 PM
No, you're not scum because of the casino.  I love casinos.  Blackjack and roulette are my SHIT.  I first started to doubt my read of you when you said:

Could kiss you on the mouth right now Powers but that would probably make people think I'm scummier.

Then, after this gem of a paragraph....

Also, I was wrong about Kirk have nothing that makes me really point a finger at anyone else but my belief is that Gooch is either mafia hard selling that Kirk was town to cover himself, or that heís telling the truth about his one shot ability or whatever.

....I'm left feeling that what I was misconstruing as 'newb town' is actually 'this guy is scummy as fuck'.



WE ARE NOW IN THE MASS CLAIM PHASE.  CLAIM YOUR ROLE/CHARACTER IN YOUR NEXT POST.

Powers - Frank Castle/Town Vig (claim unchallenged for days)

Jon - Rafael "Rafi" Hernandez/Claims Vanilla town
Gooch - Sam Stein/Claims Vanilla town
Eli - ??
Metro - ??
Rebel - ??
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Eli on July 22, 2018, 04:30:01 PM
You were correct in your initial read, Powers, donít second guess yourself

I am Leo Lieberman. Vanilla Town
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 22, 2018, 05:11:24 PM
WE ARE NOW IN THE MASS CLAIM PHASE.  CLAIM YOUR ROLE/CHARACTER IN YOUR NEXT POST.

Powers - Frank Castle/Town Vig (claim unchallenged for days)

Jon - Claims Rafael "Rafi" Hernandez/Claims Vanilla town
Gooch - Claims Sam Stein/Claims Vanilla town
Eli - Claims Leo Lieberman/Claims Vanilla Town
Metro - ??
Rebel - ??
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Metroll on July 22, 2018, 05:39:07 PM
Gunner Henderson - Tracker.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 22, 2018, 05:46:57 PM
WE ARE NOW IN THE MASS CLAIM PHASE.  CLAIM YOUR ROLE/CHARACTER IN YOUR NEXT POST.

Powers - Frank Castle/Town Vig (claim unchallenged for days)

Jon - Claims Rafael "Rafi" Hernandez/Claims Vanilla town
Gooch - Claims Sam Stein/Claims Vanilla town
Eli - Claims Leo Lieberman/Claims Vanilla Town
Metro - Claims Gunner Henderson/Claims Tracker
Rebel - ??


Gunner Henderson - Tracker.

Please give us your results thus far.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Metroll on July 23, 2018, 12:12:02 AM
Sorry - wedding season sucks ass.

Night One: Pancho (goes nowhere)
Night Two: Gates (died)
Night Three: Jon (goes nowhere) (considered Eli but he looked like he was a goner regardless)
Night Four: Eli (goes nowhere) (hence my Godfather question)
Night Five: Rebel (Kirk) (hence my vote, I figured my soft hint on day five would've been enough and not forced a claim).

Since I'll be dying tonight - I'm torn between Jon and Eli. Eli has played like scum all game but Jon's played almost too good to not be scum.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 23, 2018, 12:32:22 AM
Rebel can't be Russo though. He was off the boards for an entire night phase (one where Russo killed).
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Metroll on July 23, 2018, 12:36:32 AM
Rebel can't be Russo though. He was off the boards for an entire night phase (one where Russo killed).

Not true - I've played enough games of Talon's where he has the Godfather assigning the kill. If Russo was 3P I'd agree with you but not in this case.

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 23, 2018, 12:40:09 AM
I guess I just find it hard to believe that someone as inactive as Rebel found time to send in kills in a QT, but not visit this site/thread (despite my belief that his posts are scummy as fuck).
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 23, 2018, 12:46:28 AM
This would be a good time to hear from Rebel.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Metroll on July 23, 2018, 12:47:58 AM
I guess I just find it hard to believe that someone as inactive as Rebel found time to send in kills in a QT, but not visit this site/thread (despite my belief that his posts are scummy as fuck).

That's where I'm saying it's not necessary for Rebel to have posted it, that The Godfather ultimately chooses whom to kill and then Rebel/Russo does it. I hear you Mike that it's not necessarily that way and it could just be co-incidence that he went there. I don't know. I just take that result with the fact his shit has been scummy and am trying to put two and two together.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 23, 2018, 01:03:36 AM
I see what you're saying. I somehow had it backwards (Rebel was GF directing traffic instead of being directed).

This would be a good time to hear from Rebel.

Yup.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 23, 2018, 12:21:23 PM
Vote Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Metroll on July 23, 2018, 12:35:28 PM
Unvote:

Vote: Eli
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 23, 2018, 01:04:39 PM
Dammit. Metro you sly fox. It's you and Jon ain't it?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Eli on July 23, 2018, 01:26:55 PM
BAH!!!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 23, 2018, 01:27:39 PM
Dammit. Metro you sly fox. It's you and Jon ain't it?

Well, itís definitely Metro... unless Eli does in fact flip scum.

Not I though. So if Eli is town, it appears weíre fucked.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: Talon on July 23, 2018, 09:30:37 PM
(https://78.media.tumblr.com/a2edcc86961f37d590155ac83f5f3674/tumblr_p25ji4411u1vti6y9o1_540.gif)
DAY 6 VOTE COUNT

4 -- Eli -- (Gooch, Jon, Powers, Metro)


Not Voting --   Rebel, Eli



HOLD FOR WRITE UP!

Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 6
Post by: Talon on July 23, 2018, 09:32:31 PM
(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/137/343014.jpg)
DEAD --- ELI ---Leo Lieberman -- Vanilla Townie




IT IS NOW NIGHT 6 --- 30 minutes to send in night actions
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: Talon on July 23, 2018, 09:36:35 PM
THE NEXT NIGHT, THE MAFIA LAUGHS AT THEIR EASY HANDLING OF THE TOWN, THEY KILL GOOCH LEAVING HIM DEAD.


"WHO'S PRETTY NOW?"



(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338614.jpg)
DEAD --- GOOCH --- SAM STEIN ---x1 DAY COP -- VANILLA TOWN




GAME OVER, THE TOWN CAN NOT LYNCH SCUM -- SCUM WINS!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 23, 2018, 09:37:05 PM
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Gates on July 23, 2018, 09:38:53 PM
Nicely done team!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Gooch on July 23, 2018, 10:01:41 PM
Well done, mafia. You guys nailed it.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Pancho on July 23, 2018, 10:27:34 PM
The town has no one to blame but themselves.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Gooch on July 23, 2018, 11:03:20 PM
After Jon made the comment of my character being wrong and reading about him, I summed up that it was Jon feeding Eli. By that time it was too late.

This was fun to get back into for sure! Great game!
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Kirk on July 23, 2018, 11:06:10 PM
Was Powers a 1x vig?
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 23, 2018, 11:06:29 PM
After Jon made the comment of my character being wrong and reading about him, I summed up that it was Jon feeding Eli. By that time it was too late.

This was fun to get back into for sure! Great game!

Huh, I never said your character was wrong.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM T-Bone on July 23, 2018, 11:22:55 PM
I think I investigated Jon Night 1 so tech kill mates.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Day 5
Post by: GM Gooch on July 23, 2018, 11:26:37 PM

Iím actually going to believe his claim but not believe his result. While reading up on Stein, his character used false information.

Vote: Kirk

This is what I meant.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Gooch on July 23, 2018, 11:27:32 PM
I see the difference in what you mean, but it threw up a red flag because I looked up the character and didn't think what you said matched up. That's all I mean.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: Talon on July 23, 2018, 11:32:23 PM
(https://em.wattpad.com/dfc29fac05d0c22c2557a914a6e24cee5db05f0f/68747470733a2f2f73332e616d617a6f6e6177732e636f6d2f776174747061642d6d656469612d736572766963652f53746f7279496d6167652f4e464248425f56676b33747634513d3d2d3432333639373437302e313530353037636338663039376331653633343333323535303830312e676966)
Frank Castle -- Bulletproof Townie, x1 Vigilante
Role: You are Frank Castle, The Punisher.  Your family was murdered, your life stolen from you, but you simply Will Not Die.  Your mission is to hunt down and kill anyone and everyone involved with the murder of your family.  You are the Bulletproof Townie.  You are also a x1 Vigilante.  Once during the course of the game you may choose a player to kill.  Choose wisely, as this is the only chance youíll have, make your shot count.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated

(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338829.jpg)
David ďMicroĒ Lieberman -- Commuter*
Role: You are David Lieberman AKA Micro.  As an NSA intellegence analyst you have discovered a video incriminating several members of the government and military for illegal actions in Afghanistan.  Because of this you are on the run.  You can not go home at night, instead staying in an underground bunker to protect yourself.  You are the Town Commuter.  Each night you leave the town and are not targetable by any means.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated

(https://img.sharetv.com/shows/characters/thumbnails/marvels_the_punisher.dinah_madani.jpg)
Dinah Madani -- Town Cop
Role: You are Dinah Madani, a special FBI agent recently returning from Afghanistan.  You are the town cop.  Each night you may target one player to find if they are innocent or Guilty. 

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated

(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338812.jpg)
Curtis Hoyle -- Town Doctor
Role: You are Curtis Hoyle, a former Navy Corpseman who lost his leg in combat.  You are the Town Doctor.  Each night you may choose one player to protect from a night kill.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated

(https://media.giphy.com/media/H5iOLz1c2bpvi/giphy.gif)
Karen Page -- x1 Governor
Role: You are Karen Page a reporter in New York City, as a close confidant of Frank Castle you can use your influence with the media to avoid a lynch.  You are the Town Governor, you have a one shot ability that will allow you to void a lynch after it has been reached.  To do this, simply PM the moderator during the twilight phase of the game to use your action.  This will allow a lynched player to avoid the lynch and advance to night phase.  You may only use this once.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated

(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338614.jpg)
Sam Stein -- Vanilla
Role: You are Sam Stein, a member of the FBI New York Field Office.  You are a Vanilla Townie.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated

(http://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338825.jpg)
Sarah Lieberman -- Vanilla
Role: You are Sarah Lieberman, the wife of NSA intel analyst David Lieberman.  You are a Vanilla Townie.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated


(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/137/343014.jpg)
Leo Lieberman -- Vanilla Townie
Role: You are Leo Lieberman, the daughter of NSA intel analyst David Lieberman.  You are a Vanilla Townie.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated



(https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/villains/images/6/6e/LewisWilson.PNG/revision/latest?cb=20171122173921)
Lewis Wilson -- Paranoid Gun Owner
Role: You are former Army Infantryman Lewis Wilson.  As a member of the US Army you learned many skills, but upon your discharge from service you found yourself alone.  Abandoned by the country you swore to protect.  Now you sit at home making bombs and planning your vengeance.  You are also a Paranoid Gun Owner.  If you are targeted at night you will shoot at the person visiting you.  This too has a 50/50 chance of success. 

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated



(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338817.jpg)
Carson Wolf -- Mafia Goon
Role: You are the Special Agent in Charge of the New York Field Office of the FBI, Carson Wolf.  You are tied to William Rawlins and his group of dastardly villans. You are the Mafia Goon.  You have no ability, but you are a part of the Mafia none the less. Here is your quick topic - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/SUcR2iNprNcp

Alignment: You are a part of the Mafia

Wincon: You win when the town is out numbered.
 

(https://www.magicalquote.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Billy-Russo.jpg)
Billy Russo -- Mafia Hitman (x1 Strong Arm)
Role: You are Billy Russo, former U.S. Marine turned pioneer of the Defense Contracting Company ANVIL.  You built your empire with the secret assistance of William Rawlins of the CIA from your time in Kandahar.  You do his bidding and he keeps you afloat.  You are the Mafia Hitman.  Each night the Mafia Godfather will assign a target for you to kill.  You also have a x1 Strong Arm capability, allowing you to kill your target even if they are protected in some way. Here is your quick topic - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/SUcR2iNprNcp

Alignment: You are a part of the Mafia

Wincon: You win when the town is out numbered.


(https://static.tvmaze.com/uploads/images/medium_portrait/135/338613.jpg)
William Rollins -- Godfather / Bulletproof
Role: You are William Rollins III, As the leader of Covert Operations for the C.I.A. you have made your living dealing with the biggest secrets in the government, and youíve used your position of power to become rich through nefarious activies all around the world with no one every suspectin you due to your position in the government.  You are the Mafia Godfather.  As the leader of the Mafia, you choose who to kill each night (if you have a kill available).  You are also Bulletproof and can not be killed at night.  Here is your quick topic - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/SUcR2iNprNcp

Alignment: You are a part of the Mafia

Wincon: You win when the town is out numbered.




SAFE CLAIMS

(https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/marvelcinematicuniverse/images/1/16/Zach-lieberman.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/310?cb=20171119160024)
Zach Lieberman -- Vanilla
Role: You are Zach Lieberman, the son of NSA intel analyst David Lieberman.  You are a Vanilla Townie.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated


(https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/marvelcinematicuniverse/images/9/94/Gunner_Henderson.png/revision/latest?cb=20171219161348)
Gunner Henderson -- Town Tracker
Role: You are former Special Forces Operator Gunner Henderson.  You've seen some horrible things in your time in the military, but now that you are out you want nothing more than to keep to yourself in the woods of Kentucky and be left alone.  Because of your military training, you are the Town Tracker.  Each night you may target one player and learn who that player visited that night.

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated


(https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/marvelcinematicuniverse/images/a/a8/Rafael_Hernandez.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20171219162014)
Rafael "Rafi" Hernandez -- Town Lie Detector
Role: Rafael Hernandez, an FBI Agent you are experienced in knowing when you're being lied to.  You are the town lie detector.  Once per night you may choose one statement from a player and have it checked to be true or false. 

Alignment: You are Town

Wincon: You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Jon on July 24, 2018, 01:12:24 AM
I see the difference in what you mean, but it threw up a red flag because I looked up the character and didn't think what you said matched up. That's all I mean.

From the Marvel wiki site:

Stein and Madani then attempted to outwit their enemies by planting false information in order to capture whoever was listening to all their conversations.

Thatís where I got it from.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: GM Powers on July 24, 2018, 10:55:22 AM
I was on the right track for 90% of the game, but I allowed it to fall part at the end. The constant smoke from Eli finally turned into a fire in my mind.

Not that we could've gotten a lynch at the end, with Rebel being MIA.
Title: Re: The Black Lantern Corps Presents: Marvel's THE PUNISHER Mafia -- Night 6
Post by: Talon on July 24, 2018, 11:32:10 AM
Yeah had he been on to counter metros claim he visited Kirk it would've been interesting